Here's the full (okay, 98% accurate) list of items I added to the game's list:

Children:
Candy
Soccer Goal
Train Set from SN
Horseshoe Court
Ball Fight Arena
Slip n’ Slide
Unicorn or Dragon deco object from Generations
Sandbox
Trampoline
Bake Sale Table
“Castle” Lamp
Rocking Horse
Fire Truck Sculpture

Teen:
Snowboard
Dance Floor
Drums
Frisbee
Bean Bag
Ping Pong Table
Various Firecrackers
Generations Video Game Console
and a Painting from Uni

Elders:
Rocking Chair
The Llama Cane

Traits:

Supernatural Fan:
Potions Clutter
Magic Wand

Genius/Eccentric/Absent-Minded:
Magic 8 Ball

Photographer’s Eye:
Data Tower
Camcorder from Generations

Bookworm:
Book Clutter objects from Supernatural

Harvester:
The Harvester invention
Excitable:
Megaphone

Handy:
High-Quality Dryer
Deco computer

Natural Cook:
Knife Block
Pot Rack


Virtuoso:
Keyboard Piano
Base Game Guitar
Music Box

Athletic:
Soccer Ball

Athletic/Couch Potato:
Scoreboard Clock
Sports Pennants

Couch Potato:
Pool Lounger

Clumsy:
Kicky bag

Disciplined:
Training Dummy

Lucky:
Fortune Cookie

Neat:
Lounge Towel Rolls
Hygeinator

Neat/Slob/Hydrophobic:
Shower in a Can

Charismatic/Schmoozer:
Podium

Party Animal:
Gobo Lights
Juice Keg
Dance Floor
Effects Machine

Angler:
Fish Bowl

Commitment Issues:
Love Tester

Frugal:
Money Tree Seed

Mooch:
Deco Ramen Crates

Grumpy:
Music Box

Star Quality:
Director’s Chair

Rebellious:
Amplifier from HELS
Street Art Kit

Friendly:
Cat Clock from Generations

Savvy Sculptor:
A couple of sculptures

Perceptive:
Investigator’s Case Board

Dramatic:
Make-up Kit

Vehicle Enthusiast:
Fire Truck

Unlucky:
Life Preserver


Insane:
Rug pile from SN
Jar from SN

Socially Awkward/Loser:
Superhero Cut-out
Vintage Toy

Workaholic:
Drafting Light

Childish:
Candy
Imaginary Friend Teddy Bear
Trampoline

Good Sense of Humor:
Duck deco object

Green Thumb:
Lounge Plants

Green Thumb/Vegetarian:
All 3 Planter Bowls from SN

Daredevil:
Firecrackers

Hopeless Romantic:
Wedding Arch

Eco-Friendly:
Clothesline

Coward/Brave:
Liquid Courage Potion

Adventurous:
Mummy Snacks
Skeleton Key

Inappropriate/Irresistible:
Mistletoe

Evil:
Poisoned Apple

Flirty/Irresistible:
Heart Bed from HELS

Artistic/Avant Garde:
OLS Easel

Genius:
OLS Telescope

Family-Oriented/Nurturing:
Strollers

Over-Emotional:
Mood Lamp

Proper:
Phonograph

Night Owl/Perfectionist:
Moon Dial

Technophobe:
Grandfather Clock

Born Salesman:
Business Planner from Uni

Snob:
Makeup Case

Loves the Outdoors:
Tent
Sleeping Bag

Egyptian:
Egyptian Incense Holder
Snake Charming Basket
Scooter
Gnome

French:
French Incense Holder
Camera
Nectar Rack
Gnome

Chinese:
Incense Holder
Fortune Cookie Maker
Training Dummy
Fireworks
Gnome

OMG! Awesome idea! Thank you so much!

Amazing idea, thanks

I've never thrown a gift giving party before so I wasn't aware the gifts were actually allocated like this. This sounds like a great idea!
It's always annoying when EA don't bother to include previous EPs in new features.

Great idea! I've only once ever tried a gift party and everyone just sat there with "watch open presents" or something so I wrote it off. This makes me want to try it again!

Very useful, thank you :)

This is a great idea. Thank you - this makes me want to go in and host a gift giving party right now!

This sure beats the multiple chess tables and lamps I have received for my sims.

Very useful, thank you!

I'd use this in a heartbeat if I had Supernatural, but still have to thank you for such a great idea. When/If I get Supernatural this will be a must.

An update after getting SN: Couldn't endorse this more. It's nice knowing that all my Sims won't be getting the same gift.

Absolutely awesome! has anyone tested this without installing all the expansion pack mentioned? I only have season, supernatural, university life and pet

Thanks a lot!!

Amazing idea! Thanks!

Can I use it for 1.63?

Can you make a non WA version because that EP lags my game

I have and the majority of my guests got "missing objects" as gifts. It's like a white cube of nothing, Idk. Even my own sim got it. I'm assuming it's a item from a expansion pack that I don't have.

Maybe for evil if you ever update this, the magic mirror?

will this work with Nona's gift pile mod?

Update for newest patch?

Is it compatible with 1.67?

I own all ep, sp and store but still get "the white cube" or missing object thingy.(Are updated to 1,67) Is this because the mod has not been updated, or is it something else. Without this mod i keep getting the mistletoe over and over till im gettin crazy by the joyful clapping of the same lousy gift again and again Aaaaaarrrrgggghhh. Merry Christmas by the way and thanks for creating this sweet and uniqe mod

WHat a great idea, love it!