Who was she is she a cyborg or is she an alien.
Who was her original surname
Who was she? where did she come from?
Will we ever know?

1: 50% SimIrish from dad, and 50% native Brontesian from mom. Full human. Well maybe 0.01 Dryad from dryads spawning in either SimIreland or Bronte Island in their ancient history, but other than that no supernatural heritage.
2: Original surname was Bronte, because her dad, Horatio Nelsim, became Lord of Bronte Island. Susan's mom's original name was Alenna Leuppi.
3: She is from a boat. She moved on land (Futura Pyres) as a teen, to date Boyd, who had broken up with Helen Hall (yes from moonlight falls) to date Susan.
4: We will most likely never have a sims game where the premades are set further back from the sims 3, so our only hope for a canon maiden name for Susan is to bring back family tree ancestors in a Sunset Valley remake.

Peterson if you follow my theory of her being Tara in a future life and another theory (not mine) that she is the illegitimate child of geoff Rutherford and Jessica Peterson .

I don't think Jessica and Geoff would've been together. Jessica is much more likely to go gay after Marissa since Jessica is turned off by red hair and turned on by jewelry and makeup. Also they do not know each other at the start of the game.

Unless you mean they met, got drunk, had a child together, and somehow shipped her off to the past so she can be an Adult in TS3.

If Tara is a deaged Susan she propably is'nt the offspring of TS2 sims unless Tara timetravelled to the past and changed her name?

So she could have two maiden names: Bronte when she's Susan, then she becomes immortal, ages down, and changes her name, she becomes Tara Peterson instead and pretends to be Jessica's illegittimate child, who then gets adopted by Armand.

yes i was reffering to them having a one night stand and tara kinda looks like them right

She is a swarthy redhead with plump lips and upturned eyes but otherwise not much.

Not even based on the same face template. Tara is clearly a tweaked face one, Jessica and Geoff are tweaked Face 16.

ah well i tried

She will always be Susanna Amanda Bronte to me, whatever her ingame name is.
Just like how Tracer is named Lena Oxton even if that is not her ingame name.

Actually i invented an ancestor of Susan named, Bronte Summerdream. She is a fairy and cousins with Titania.

Bronte is from southern Ukraine, she spoke a Turkic language.

So the actual answer would be (in that version) Shes part Fairy, with Most Sims being part supernatural. Hence the weirder hair and eye colors and other stuff.

3 gen 2026: maybe its five since the thread name is susan five, or it could be different in each savefile

Or she could be related to claire ursine!

I had an OC that was known by two names, Susan Azerbaycan and Star Trey

Also technically the maiden name would be five as in this thread name or bronte as in her and Blair and Boyd bio files or whatever fits the save. So if i roll her in something more casual she might be a smith or jones but if its more magical she might be zaherialar or oganessian. I propably wont be using her for a while and im trying to avoid the prominence of the premade sims tag in my blog and am trying to do my own stories.

Fun fact Blair was a rushed sim, her swimwear doesnt match, with the top being a default color. Also the sim bios link to Bronte but the family bio links to Wainwright and the genetics may not much make sense, Blair, cycl0n3, Emma, all have default hair colors shared with various other Sunset Valley premades. Yet Boyd has a customized cyan and blond hair color nobody else has, and Susan has a customized red hair with orange and full-red streaks and tips, she only shares it with claire ursine.